Skip to main content

HCOL Home ownership: Is the Mortgage "Tax Ceiling" a reason to put higher downpayment

I’m currently house hunting for a townhome in HCOL area in the $1.2M – $1.4M range. Like many, I’ve always operated under the "Standard Rule": Put 20% down to avoid PMI, then keep the rest of your cash in the market (S&P 500) to outpace the mortgage interest, especially since the interest is tax-deductible.

However, I just had a "lightbulb moment" regarding the IRS limits that changes the math significantly.

**The Realization:** The Mortgage Interest Deduction (MID) is capped at **$750k of principal**.

If I buy a $1.2M home with 20% down:

* **Down Payment:** $240k

* **Mortgage:** $960k

* **The "Tax Gap":** $210k of that mortgage receives **zero** tax benefit.

Essentially, I’m paying the full 6.5% interest (or whatever the current rate is) on that top $210k without the "subsidy" of a tax write-off. Meanwhile, my "guaranteed" return on cash in a HYSA is only \~4.5% (pre-tax).

**The Pivot:** I have enough liquidity to potentially put down $460k (roughly 38%) to bring the loan amount exactly to $750k.

**The Question:** Does it make more sense to "overpay" the down payment to hit that $750k sweet spot?

By doing a 38% down payment:

  1. **Guaranteed Return:** I’m effectively getting a guaranteed 6.5% return on that extra $210k by not paying interest on it.
  2. **Tax Efficiency:** 100% of my remaining mortgage interest becomes deductible.
  3. **Cash Flow:** My monthly DTI improves significantly.

**The Trade-off:** I’d have to liquidate some taxable brokerage assets to make this happen.

Am I overthinking the $750k limit, or is this the standard "pro move" for HCOL buyers to avoid holding "expensive" non-deductible debt? Would love to hear from anyone who has run these numbers or chose one path over the other.

**TL;DR:** Should I stick to 20% down and hold a $960k loan, or put \~38% down to cap the loan at the $750k tax-deductible limit?

submitted by /u/Shehbaz_Jaffer
[link] [comments]

source https://www.reddit.com/r/RealEstate/comments/1pxlfe5/hcol_home_ownership_is_the_mortgage_tax_ceiling_a/
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

North Carolina – “One to Buy; Two to Sell”

I realize I will likely have to contact a real estate attorney but also hoping to hear insights and experiences from others! I have a house in NC that I bought by myself in 2009, and paid off, in full, in 2022. I got married in 2023. My spouse and I have not lived in the house as our "marital residence". We have maintained separate residences even after we got married. (That a separate topic!). I am now selling this house. Realtors have told us that my husband has to sign the deed at time of transfer but I am not convinced since the house has not been our marital residence. The realtors like to use the phrase "one to buy; two to sell", which seems like a broad-stroke statement which is not applicable under all circumstances. And of course, the realtors don’t realize the details of my specific circumstances: I purchased and paid for the house in full prior to marriage Only my name is on the deed And most importantly, we have never lived in the house as a marit...
Post a Comment
Read more

Aren't comps/CMAs useless with buyer credits at close happening now?

I'm looking into buying a new construction townhouse in my HCOL US city. I'm seeing builders offering interest rate buydowns worth $20k-$60k on $800k homes (rather than just lowering prices) in order to keep their comps high for their other units, now that buyer demand has been declining. I asked my agent about these, and he said these buydowns aren't even the full story: buyers can write all kinds of other credits into an offer, like their closing costs, prepaid sewer fees, etc. Apparently cash buyers can just write in a "buyer credit at close" for any amount in their offer. So a new townhouse that appeared to sell for $800k in the MLS might have actually been a cash offer with a $100k+ buyer credit at close, meaning the buyer only spent $700k or less in total, but to the rest of the world they can only see the $800k! So that made me realize I can't trust comps/CMAs for other new construction townhouses. The sales prices could be way lower than they appear...
1 comment
Read more

Co-signing as non-primary resident - effect on size of required downpayment & first time home buyer status?

Contemplating co-signing on a house with my mom and splitting the mortgage payment. I currently have a significantly higher income and much better credit than her. I'm looking at potential home costs and related downpayments but have difficulty using some of the online estimators. From my perspective, this would be somewhat of an investment purchase (I intend to stay in my current location in a different state and contribute to the mortgage), however, for my mom, this would be a primary residence. For purposes of the downpayment size and the type of mortgage arrangement, would it be an investment property or a primary residence? Many thanks for any help. submitted by /u/piercalicious [link] [comments] source https://www.reddit.com/r/RealEstate/comments/km4hvl/cosigning_as_nonprimary_resident_effect_on_size/
Post a Comment
Read more